The vessel got off her course in the blackness of the night, rain contributing to the low visibility. Dog Island Light was picked up soon after the Konini passed Centre Island. The distance between the two points is approximately 25 miles. The Konini was standing well out, a course being set to carry her round behind Dog Island, the usual course followed by vessels making round the coast for Dunedin. However, the master, who had been on the bridge since 6pm, lost sight of Dog Island Light in a blinding rain squall. Dog Island Light was not picked up again, and the first realisation of danger came when the Bluff Hill loamed out of the darkness, right ahead. The Konini struck head on, losing her rudder in doing so. When she settled her bow pointed out to sea, as though she had endeavoured to make seaward, and had struck the stern. She lifted and crunched on the rocks many times, until her plates were badly gashed. She made water rapidly and began to settle.
At the inquiry into the loss of the Konini the court held that, the patent log not having been in use, and the bearings taken off Centre and Dog Islands being too approximate, and from the fact taht neither land nor lights could be seen and the vessel bieng in confined waters, the master shoud have altered course when Dog Island was lost, by heading the vessel clear of the strait and awaiting clearer weather; but, while censuring him, the court did not suspend his certificate, but ordered him to pay 40 pounds towards the costs of the inquiry. INGRAM C W N (1990) "New Zealand Shipwrecks - 195 Years of Disasters at Sea" Beckett Books Ltd. pg 346-347